Reflections on the Two Fisherman


Reflections on the Two Fisherman

W. Somerset Maugham was, according to many accounts, the most widely read novelist since Charles Dickens.

I first became interested in Maugham in the 1980’s when I was taking a film class with artist Janet Echelman at Harvard. As Janet mentions in her interview with me (click here for the my interview with Janet), she recalls seeing my film on the “Sadhu” (for which I traveled to the Indian Himalayas; based on my interest in Sanskrit literature in general and The Upanishads in particular.


It was around that time that I came across “The Razor’s Edge” by Maugham. It was not the book that intrigued me at this point – it was the title. Maugham took the title directly from this phrase in The Katha Upanishad:

“The path of salvation is narrow,

Narrow as the edge of a razor.”

The Upanishads, translated by Juan Mascaro for Penguin.

I became intrigued how a very formal, Edwardian English gentleman like Maugham would show such a genuine interest in The Upanishads. As I researched the subject more, I learned that Maugham had actually visited Tamil Nadu in India (where Mahabalipuram is located). There, he had visited the Ramana ashram and met with a Maharashi. This was late 1930’s – three full decades before The Beatles became interested in Indian philosophy.

Maugham met with a Maharashi 3 decades before The Beatles became interested in Indian Philosophy and met with Maharashi Mahesh Yogi

A Thorough Nuisance

If I read a really good and well-researched book I am invariably compelled to make a thorough nuisance of myself by contacting the author and letting them know how positively I feel about their work. My most frequent victims are ancient historians and classical scholars. Recent victims include Dr. Henriette van der Blom, who teaches Classics at Oxford, and Dr. Christopher Krebs, who teaches Classics at Harvard. Since my contacting them, they have both written for Mez Mag – Henriette on Cicero and Christopher on Tacitus. My current victim is the author Lewis Hyde whom I had to call up immediately after reading his now classic book, The Gift.

About 20 years ago, I read the best biography of W. Somerset Maugham ever, entitled “Willie: Life of W. Somerset Maugham” (1990) by Robert Calder. Here is the Kirkus Review:

“This biography of the most widely read novelist since Dickens is also the most balanced and compassionate life to date… Calder makes clear, this complex man, perhaps because of his sense of the futility of life, responded to life with more warmth and generosity than he has been given credit for. A much-needed, welcome corrective to earlier biographies – a pleasure to read.”  – The Kirkus Review

So, being the thorough nuisance that I am, I called Professor Calder up on the phone.

Bob was in Canada and I was in California. We began a warm friendship over the years and eventually Bob and I met up in California and worked on a multi-cultural literature project together with Professor Jeremy Geidt at Harvard. This resulted in our dispatching Jeremy to teach at The Doon School in the Dehra Dun hillstation near the Indian Himalayas.

As part of the schoolwide multi-cultural initiative, Jeremy taught Shakespeare at Doon School and he learned Sanskrit plays by Patañjali, Kālidāsa and Bhavabhuti. He brought this knowledge of Sanskrit drama back to students at Harvard.

Jeremy Geidt also studied Indo-European interconnections such as the fact that Kālidāsa’s play, Sakuntala, was a strong influence on Goethe’s Faust, and that the German philosopher Arthur Schopenhauer helped to introduce The Upanishads to a wider European readership.


About Robert Calder


Emeritus Professor of English of the University of Saskatchewan, Robert Calder is the author and editor of ten books. Among his volumes published internationally are W. Somerset Maugham and the Quest for Freedom (Heinemann, UK, 1972; Doubleday, USA; Hokuseido Press, Tokyo) and Willie: The Life of W. Somerset Maugham (Heinemann, UK, 1989; St. Martin’s Press, USA; Interdialect, Russia). The latter won the 1989 Governor General’s Literary Award for Non-Fiction in Canada. He has also written the introductions and explanatory notes to four Maugham novels – Of Human BondageThe Moon and SixpenceThe Magician, and Mrs Craddock – for the NY Penguin Classics series

Calder is also the author of Beware the British Serpent: The Role of Writers in British Propaganda in the United States, 1939-1945 (2004), for which he won two Saskatchewan Book Awards, and A Richer Dust: Family, Memory and the Second World War (2004). For these books and numerous articles, essays, and reviews, Calder was given the University of Saskatchewan’s Distinguished Researcher Award in 2005.

He continues to publish eclectically, writing some sports history, working on a book about the first contact between the Maya and the Spanish in sixteenth-century Yucatán, and researching a book about film adaptations of the works of Somerset Maugham.

“Mr. Robert Calder has written a biography of W. Somerset Maugham in order to redress, nicely, some recent studies of the man who was probably our century’s most popular novelist as well as the most successful of Edwardian playwrights.”

– Gore Vidal’s review in The New York Review of Books


Just One Question

Bob, my story of The Two Fishermen of Mahabalipuram is broadly about the road to discovery or re-discovery. It is about the journey toward finding true meaning and purpose. How does this story relate to Maugham’s classic novel, The Razor’s Edge?

Response from Bob


I was fascinated how, in “The Two Fishermen of Mahabalipuram,” you turned Janet Echelman’s story of artistic inspiration and discovery (so well articulated in her TED Talk on “Imagination”) around and gave us an entirely different perspective of the same event.

Janet’s experience of finding her own highly original form of artistic expression in such a kind of epiphany is probably not unique. Behind the work of Jackson Pollock, Pablo Picasso, and Georgia O’Keeffe, I suspect, there was a moment when, working toward their own artistic vision, they suddenly realized that they had found─almost by accident, or at least trial-and-error─a form that was truly new and original.

MaughamOHBSomerset Maugham wrote about artists, the artistic temperament, and artistic discovery in a number of his works. In his bildungsroman Of Human Bondage, he devotes a number of chapters to the Paris artistic scene at the turn of the twentieth century when his protagonist, Philip Carey, attempts to become a painter. Wisely, he concludes that he does not have the burning passion to paint that consumes and drives the most creative figures and he returns to England to a safer and more conventional life as a country doctor. Of Human Bondage is an autobiographical novel, and, though Maugham himself became a qualified medical doctor, he did not follow Philip’s path, instead striking out to pursue writing; ultimately becoming one of English literature’s most published authors.

Maugham, however, was always torn between the artistic life, with its unconventionality, risks, and frequent inner demons, and the conventional life of the English upper-middle class into which he had been born. His next novel, The Moon and Sixpence, published four years after Of Human Bondage, deals with this tension in the story of Charles Strickland, a middle-aged conventional English stockbroker who abandons career and family to paint. Maugham very cleverly uses the narrative voice of a conventional, proper English gentlemen to tell the story of a man so overwhelmingly possessed by artistic passion. In doing so, he again represents the tension within himself between artist and the gentleman.

MaughamMASLike Paul Gauguin, on whom he is loosely based, Charles Strickland finds Europe, even the artistic, bohemian milieu of Paris, too banal and restrictive. He sails to Tahiti. There, like Janet with the fishermen’s nets, he finds his subjects and, more important, his form, and produces paintings of a sort never seen before. Maugham, of course, can offer his readers only words to describe Strickland’s achievement, but they suggest the striking, intense paintings of Gauguin. One might argue that Strickland and Gauguin would not have discovered that essential unique vision and form had they not found their ways to French Polynesia.

Maugham, himself, found inspiration in leaving his conventional life at his villa in Cap Ferrat, along the French Riviera, and his luxurious suite in London’s Dorchester Hotel, when he traveled to India in the 1930s.

There he became fascinated by Vedanta and Eastern mysticism, and, rather surprisingly for a man in his late sixties, began to write another bildungsroman, this time the tale of a young American who abandons a career in business in order to search the world for spiritual truth and serenity. The result was The Razor’s Edge, (1944), a book arguably 30 years ahead of its time but timeless in its theme. The protagonist, Larry Darrell, lives in Chicago in the 1920s and is expected to pursue the American Dream of financial and social success, and to marry the beautiful upper-class young woman who will stand at his side as he climbs the social ladder.


Like so many young men, however, he is profoundly changed by his experience in the First World War, the horrors of what he has seen knocking him off the path he expected to follow. The remainder of the novel recounts his spiritual quest, which takes him to France and ultimately to India, where he finds the spiritual foundation for his life. Maugham ends the novel, shrewdly I think, by describing Larry back in New York, perhaps working as a taxi driver, but able to remain spiritually grounded while living in modern, material, capitalist United States because he has found inner satisfaction.

I think both Maugham’s own experiences in India, and Larry’s in the war and in the ashrams, can be said to be the epiphany that is described within “The Two Fishermen of Mahabalipuram”.

Or at least they can be said to be those events in one’s life where one is shaken off the conventional path and onto something unplanned which turns out to be surprisingly productive. And many times, as the story underlines, the catalytic event can first seem catastrophic or at least negative.

Books have been written about artistic creativity, and I have nothing original to add. I do, though, believe that the greatest works of art are a result of some original vision coming to an artist who has developed the craft─often after years of painstaking effort─to be able to realize that vision on canvas, in clay, in sound, or on the page. When we hear the marvelous ragas performed by Ravi Shankar or Ali Akbar Khan, music that unfolds over hours of imaginative improvisation, we have to remember that these great musicians can operate with such seeming freedom of expression only because they have had years of apprenticeship. In the Sixties, when George Harrison and other Western musicians became excited by Indian classical music, they were eager to play the sitar and emulate Shankar, Khan and others. As reverential as their attitude was, however, they needed to remember that such musicians were not permitted to perform in public until they had spent at least a decade perfecting their craft.